The Rankings
Sagamore 8 year old Bottled in Bond bottle

No. 11Top 20 of 2026

Sagamore 8 year old Bottled in Bond

Rye

points

Whisky Advocate rating

Origin
USA
ABV
50%
Price
$60
Paired withOliva CigarsOliva CigarsOliva Serie V Melanio Robusto

Whisky Advocate review

Tasting notes

Panel rating
93 points
Style
Rye
Origin
USA
ABV
50%
Price
$60

The oldest Sagamore-distilled whiskey released to date, as this Baltimore-based rye maker moves further away from its reliance on sourcing. From start to finish, this is everything you’d want from a Maryland-style rye: The nose leads with decadent aromas of caramel, brown sugar, vanilla, and Cinnabon, while the palate packs in the spice with dill, chocolate chiles, and nutmeg. It saves the best for last, fading out with flavors of Rocky Road, sweet cinnamon, chocolate, and black-and-white cookies.—Danny Brandon

The pairing
Whisky AdvocateOliva CigarsOliva Cigars
Sagamore 8 year old Bottled in Bond bottle

No. 1193 points

Sagamore 8 year old Bottled in Bond

Oliva Serie V Melanio Robusto

Paired withOliva CigarsOliva Cigars

Serie V Melanio Robusto

Why they work together

The rye’s baked apple, cherry and brown sugar complement the Melanio’s coffee, cedar and baking-spice character without requiring a heavier Maduro.

Explore Oliva
No. 11: Sagamore 8 year old Bottled in Bond | Whisky Advocate Top 20 of 2026